Everything

Linktree acquires social media scheduler tool Plann

Link-in-bio platform Linktree announced Thursday that it has acquired social media scheduling tool Plann for an undisclosed amount.

While Sydney, Australia-headquartered Plann will continue to operate as usual for now, Linktree is set to integrate its social scheduling tool into its platform in the coming months. This means that users will soon have access to features like social media planning and auto-posting for platforms like TikTok, Facebook, LinkedIn and Instagram. It’s unclear whether Linktree plans to incorporate all of Plann’s features, such as its AI-powered caption generator. 

Linktree didn’t specify how much the new scheduling tool would cost for users. Plann users will transition to Linktree once it officially launches. 

The company said that the entire Plann team, including employees and contractors, are joining Linktree, including founder Christy Laurence, who will be a permanent team member.

According to the company, social scheduling is one of Linktree’s most requested features, as it helps creators streamline their content distribution process and save time.

“The 50 million creators and businesses using Linktree are busy producing content, and many are juggling multiple ventures – we strive to simplify how they manage, grow, and monetize their audience. Adding social scheduling to Linktree will make it even simpler to distribute inspiring content, so our Linkers can get back to doing what they love – creating,” Linktree co-founder and CEO Alex Zaccaria said in a statement. 

This marks Linktree’s fourth acquisition, following three other investments made by the company in recent years: link-in-bio competitors Koji and Bento, as well as Odesli, the automated music link aggregation platform.

Separately, Linktree launched its beta social commerce offering earlier this year, giving creators the ability to add storefronts to their link-in-bio pages and take 12%-15% commission on sales. 

Linktree touts over 50 million users.

Read More

Epic Games’ ‘MegaGrant’ makes EU alternative app store, AltStore PAL, available for free

AltStore PAL, an app that takes advantage of the EU’s Digital Markets Act (DMA) to bring a third-party app store to EU users, is now available for free, thanks to Epic Games. The app maker announced via social media posts on Wednesday it’s the latest recipient of a “MegaGrant” monetary award from Fortnite maker Epic Games, which will allow it to cover Apple’s Core Technology fee going forward, as well as make AltStore PAL free to users, no more subscription required.

The alternative app store was created by Riley Testut, the developer behind the video game emulator Delta, and longtime friend and business partner Shane Gill. The app launched following the implementation of the EU’s DMA, initially with two apps — Delta and the AltStore’s own clipboard manager, Clip. Unlike Apple’s App Store, anyone can distribute their app on the AltStore through self-publishing, the company said.

Though AltStore was experimenting with new business models for app distribution and monetization, like Patreon-backed apps, the app required a small €1.50 annual subscription fee from users. Testut had explained that the decision to charge a subscription was solely due to the fact that the AltStore PAL wouldn’t otherwise be able to pay Apple’s Core Technology Fee themselves as a donations-backed, free app.

As the company shared in its social media posts, Epic Games granted the AltStore PAL a MegaGrant that it plans to use to cover Apple’s Core Technology Fee going forward. As a result, it is dropping subscription pricing.

MegaGrants, first announced in 2019, come from a $100 million fund from Epic Games designed to support “game developers, enterprise professionals, media and entertainment creators, students, educators, and tool developers worldwide” who are working with Epic’s Unreal Engine or improving open source capabilities in the 3D graphics community. The awards from the grants range from $5,000 to $500,000, Epic said when debuting the new fund.

Epic Games declined to disclose the size of the grant awarded AltStore PAL, when reached for comment.

The company, however, has been a notable thorn in Apple’s side for years, after suing the iPhone maker over antitrust concerns with regard to its App Store. Though Apple largely won that case, the judge decided that developers should be allowed to point users to their own websites for transactions and payments — something they can now do but only for a slightly reduced commission of 27%, Apple decided. Epic Games has also loudly criticized Apple’s implementation of its DMA compliance plan, which introduced new business rules for developers in the region and added new fees. That includes the Core Technology Fee, which Epic is now covering for AltStore PAL.

In addition to dropping the subscription fee, AltStore PAL told its users who already paid they will not be charged again when it comes time for renewal.

Read More

CodeRabbit raises $16M to bring AI to code reviews

Code reviews — peer reviews of code that help devs improve code quality — are time-consuming. According to one source, 50% of companies spend two to five hours a week on them. Without enough people, code reviews can be overwhelming and take devs away from other important work.

Harjot Gill thinks that code reviews can be largely automated using artificial intelligence. He’s the co-founder and CEO of CodeRabbit, which analyzes code using AI models to provide feedback.

Prior to starting CodeRabbit, Gill was the senior director of technology at datacenter software company Nutanix. He joined the company when Nutanix acquired his startup, Netsil, in March 2018. CodeRabbit’s other founder, Gur Singh, previously led dev teams at white-label healthcare payments platform Alegeus.

According to Gill, CodeRabbit’s platform automates code reviews using “advanced AI reasoning” to “understand the intent” behind code and deliver “actionable,” “human-like” feedback to devs.

“Traditional static analysis tools and linters are rule-based and often generate high false-positive rates, while peer reviews are time-consuming and subjective,” Gill told TechCrunch. “CodeRabbit, by contrast, is an AI-first platform.”

These are bold claims with a lot of buzzwords. Unfortunately for CodeRabbit, anecdotal evidence suggests that AI-powered code reviews tend to be inferior compared to human-in-the-loop ones.

In a blog post, Graphite’s Greg Foster talks about internal experiments to apply OpenAI’s GPT-4 to code reviews. While the model would catch some useful things — like minor logical errors and spelling mistakes — it generated lots of false positives. Even attempts at fine-tuning didn’t dramatically reduce these, according to Foster.

These aren’t revelations. A recent Stanford study found that engineers who use code-generating systems are more likely to introduce security vulnerabilities in the apps they develop. Copyright is an ongoing concern, as well.

There are also logistical drawbacks of using AI for code reviews. As Foster notes, more traditional code reviews force engineers to learn through sessions and conversations with their developer peers. Offloading reviews threatens this knowledge sharing.

Gill feels differently. “CodeRabbit’s AI-first approach improves code quality and significantly reduces the manual effort required in the code review process,” he said.

Some folks are buying the sales pitch. Around 600 organizations are paying for CodeRabbit’s services today, Gill claims, and CodeRabbit is in pilots with “several” Fortune 500 companies.

It also has investments: CodeRabbit today announced a $16 million Series A funding round led by CRV, with participation from Flex Capital and Engineering Capital. Bringing the company’s total raised to just under $20 million, the new cash will be put toward expanding CodeRabbit’s 10-person sales and marketing functions and product offerings, with a focus on enhancing its security vulnerability analysis capabilities.

“We’ll invest in deeper integrations with platforms like Jira and Slack, as well as AI-driven analytics and reporting tools,” Gill said, adding that Bay Area-based CodeRabbbit is in the process of setting up a new office in Bangalore as it roughly doubles the size of the team. “The platform will also introduce advanced AI automation for dependency management, code refactoring, unit test generation and documentation generation.”

Read More

X begins rolling out support for passkeys on Android

X, formerly known as Twitter, has announced that it’s rolling out support for passkeys on Android. The launch comes as the social network rolled out support for passkeys to all iOS users back in April.

Passkey logins make it harder for bad actors to remotely access your accounts since they would also need physical access to your phone. Unlike standard logins, passkeys use Face ID or Touch ID, a PIN, or a physical security authentication key to validate logins.

Passkeys are a relatively new technology that removes the need to rely on username and password combinations, which can be susceptible to phishing and other issues.

X is one of many tech companies to introduce passkey support in the past year or so. Other big names that have done so include Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Google, PayPal, TikTok, WhatsApp and GitHub.

On X, the addition of passkey support could help users who previously relied on SMS 2FA, an option that X removed for free users last year.

You can enable passkeys on X by logging into the app, clicking “Your account” in the navigation bar and then selecting “Settings and privacy.” Next, you need to click “Security and account access,” and then “Security.” Under the “Additional password protection” options select “Passkey.” Click the “Add a passkey” option and then follow the prompts to enable the feature.

Read More

Lockheed Martin to buy satellite maker Terran Orbital in $450M deal

Lockheed Martin is sweeping in to save satellite manufacturer Terran Orbital from its dwindling cash reserves and mounting debt, in a $450 million take-private deal that’s expected to close before the end of the year. 

The defense giant will buy Terran for $0.25 per share and retire its existing debt. Lockheed, which holds a 28.3% stake in Terran Orbital, strategically invested in Terran Orbital through its Lockheed Martin Ventures investing arm in 2017, 2020 and 2022. This will be the first LMV portfolio company that Lockheed Martin will acquire since the fund was founded in 2007. Satellite bus contracts for Lockheed represent around 70% of the company’s revenue and 91% of the company’s backlog. 

Terran Orbital got a major boost at the beginning of 2023, when it announced a $2.4 billion, 300-satellite deal for Rivada Space Networks, a company that wants to build a satellite communications constellation. However, Rivada delayed its incremental payments toward the order, and in its recent earnings report Terran Orbital said it was removing the Rivada deal from its backlog. 

Lockheed first proposed acquiring the company for more than $500 million in March. Terran Orbital responded by introducing a limited-duration stockholder rights plan, or a “poison pill,” to prevent the buy-out. Lockheed dropped its bid in May.

Terran Orbital reported cash reserves of $14.6 million as of July 31, down from $30.6 million as of the end of June. It told regulators on August 12 that it was pursuing “a range of strategic options” to address its need for cash. As of market close on Wednesday, Terran Orbital stock was trading at $0.40 per share. 

Terran Orbital is now the second space company to leave the public markets after entering them at billion-dollar-plus valuations. Terran Orbital made its public debut at a $1.8 billion valuation; Astra Space, the other space company that finalized its take-private deal over the summer, went public at a valuation of $2.1 billion. At the time of their private deals, both companies were worth just a fraction of those amounts. 

Read More

Waymo to double down on winter testing its robotaxis

Waymo regularly takes its autonomous vehicles on winter road trips to test the cars in snowy environments. In 2017, it was Michigan. Last year, it was Buffalo. 

This year, Waymo will hit multiple wintry locales, including Truckee, California; Upstate New York; and Michigan, from the Upper Peninsula to the metro Detroit area. 

Waymo didn’t say whether it would take its Zeekr vehicles up north for testing, but the company will be putting both its fifth- and sixth-generation Driver through its paces. The hardware for the sixth-generation Driver is designed for winter environments, with sensors that can melt snow off them. 

Details of the tests are scant, but we do know the tests will always feature a human safety driver behind the wheel.

Read More

AI social media vetting startup Ferretly secures $2.5M, launches election personnel screening tool

AI social media vetting startup Ferretly has raised $2.5 million in seed funding and is launching a new platform designed to screen election personnel. Founded in 2019, Ferretly leverages AI to scan social media and publicly available online data to uncover potential risks and behaviors that traditional background checks may overlook.

The startup is the brainchild of Darrin Lipscomb, who previously founded software startups Pipestream and Avrio, which sold to BMC Software and Hitachi, respectively.

Lipscomb told TechCrunch that Ferretly is designed to help hiring managers ensure that the person they’re hiring aligns with their company’s values. The idea is to make sure you’re not hiring someone who’s making threats or sharing racist remarks online, just like you wouldn’t want to hire someone who’s committed a crime. 

“It’s really a question of character,” Lipscomb said. “Your normal background check is built around the physical world, right? What crime occurred in the physical world? Now, as more people sort of become interconnected and move online, it was really about looking at the digital persona. We can glean some unique insights for hiring managers, about this individual, specifically their character.”

As we near the 2024 presidential election, Ferretly is debuting a new Election Personnel Screening Platform that screens candidates, poll workers, canvassers and other election personnel to mitigate risks of disruptive behaviors. 

The election personnel screening platform assesses digital red flags, including inflammatory rhetoric or hate speech, disparaging or bullying behavior, questionable conduct like drug use, nudity or violence, and connections to extremist groups or individuals. 

Image Credits: Ferretly

Ferretly recently enhanced its image classification tool to detect offensive gestures, such as the middle finger, and extremist symbols like Nazi insignias and terrorist group flags. The platform can also identify images of weapons, including firearms, sharp objects and explosives.

While Ferretly scans social media platforms, it also scans web pages and news articles to highlight additional information. 

After Ferretly conducts a scan of someone’s social media and publicly available data, the platform summarizes its findings in a report that allows hiring managers to quickly glean insights about the person. The report includes risk indicators, flagged content and behavioral insights.

Ferretly says it follows all federal and state/provincial laws when it comes to pre-employment social media screening and protecting your data. Although the startup’s tool may seem creepy, it serves as a sobering reminder that everything you say online leaves a digital footprint. We live in a time where people are often fired for their social media posts, so it’s no surprise that a tool like Ferretly exists.

The startup has customers in 32 countries and over 1,000 clients across various industries. Some notable clients include Deloitte, Blizzard Entertainment and Paramount Global. The startup’s tools are also used by nonprofits, public sector organizations like police forces and even political parties in the U.K., New Zealand and Canada. 

Lipscomb says Ferretly also does quite a bit of influencer vetting, as brands want to make sure they aren’t hiring someone who has made hateful or threatening remarks online to represent their brand. The startup’s tools were also used by some NFL teams during the draft.

As for the new funding, Lipscomb says most of it will go toward marketing efforts to build awareness around Ferretly, while the rest will go toward research and development. 

The funding was led by David Dickerson, chairman and founder of Accurate Background, a provider of employment background screening services.

Read More

TipRanks, an AI-based stock tip evaluator created after its founder got burned by bad advice, sells for $200M to Prytek

Financial chatter has been a major traffic spinner on social media, but it can be challenging (if not impossible) to separate useful signals from the noise. A company called TipRanks uses AI and other analytics to try to make better sense of all that. And now, on the back of its growing popularity, it is getting snapped up for $200 million by Prytek, a developer of business process products for financial services, human resources and other enterprise verticals.

TipRanks uses natural-language processing and data science techniques to build datasets and other insights based on the vast quantities of market data on the internet. It’s currently used by some 50 million monthly active individual users, some of whom use a limited free plan, and some of whom pay either $30/month or $50/month for more enhanced datasets and other material. Enterprise customers meanwhile include Nasdaq, Robinhood, CIBC, Morgan Stanley, TD and Rakuten alongside other hedge funds, banks, brokers and exchanges.

Prytek had already been a big investor in TipRanks since 2017, most recently leading a $77 million round in the company in 2021.

Ironically for a company that has built a business on helping people make smarter bids on stocks, TipRanks was the subject of a little bidding war itself.

TechCrunch understands that a popular online destination for financial news and data — possibly the biggest in part because it doesn’t use a paywall — approached TipRanks also with an acquisition offer of a similar amount. As Prytek was already a major investor, it was made aware of the offer and made one of its own, a deal that made strategic sense, since the plan is not only to continue growing its base of individual users, but to make deeper inroads into more enterprise customers.

“Prytek owns a few other big companies that are active and financial services,” said Uri Gruenbaum, TipRanks’ CEO, in an interview with TechCrunch. “They were able to open a lot of doors for us. And when I mean doors, I mean getting tier-one banks to work with us.”

From what we understand, Prytek now has more than 90% of the company in this deal.

“They didn’t want to sell us at this point, and so they bought out all the other investors and the founders and the employees,” Gruenbaum said. There is in fact one outstanding existing investor who has yet to sell up but the name and other details are not being disclosed.

TipRanks’ growth up to now has come on the back of some bigger trends in the worlds of finance and technology.

The stock market has always thrived on the back of chatter about what to buy and sell, and which business is doing better and which is not. That was a situation that went into high gear with the rise of social media, where sites like Reddit, Twitter (now X) and others became hotbeds for hot-takes and lots more. The sea of rank-and-file analysts from financial houses writing and publishing financial reports swelled with a new wave of armchair analysts. But without any quality control, it’s become a risky process to really know what information might be more or less credible.

That situation occasionally spills over into the absurd, when you consider the immense speculation, disseminated on social media, that swirls around cryptocurrency — whose utility is questionable at best, or outright illegal and very bad at worst — or the infamous GameStop Squeeze.

Couple this with the rise of apps like Revolut, Robinhood and eToro. These platforms have blown up and democratized the stock market, making it significantly easier for ordinary people to buy and sell shares in public companies alongside those like institutional investors and high-net-worth individuals, which have traditionally come to the table with significant money to put down.

You might say these apps make it easier to make money, yet arguably they make it all too easy to lose money, too.

All those dynamics — both good and bad — of the modern trading landscape were something that Gruenbaum learned about the hard way.

It was 2012, and while working at a company called ARX, Gruenbaum had received a bonus of $20,000. He excitedly decided he would invest the money — an unexpected windfall — in the stock market, following what he thought was a bona fide good recommendation he came across online.

ARX still lives (it was acquired eventually by Docusign), but that bonus did not: Gruenbaum got burned by what turned out to be a very bad tip and he lost the money.

Not all was lost, though. The scenario became a source of inspiration for him, leading him to co-found TipRanks with chief technology officer Gilad Gat to make better sense of all that noise.

TipRanks essentially was created to address both the challenge and opportunity at hand. It uses natural-language processing to parse all of the conversation and content creation that is taking place, which can include published reports but also posts on social media. Through that, it produces a vast amount of aggregated data on different companies, industries and financial instruments; and it identifies and ranks different analysts, from those working at the big banks through to “finfluencers.”

Early on, Gruenbaum said that TipRanks would get calls from analysts who didn’t want to get tracked by it — namely if they’d made a bad call or two.

“We had analysts complaining that they couldn’t find new jobs because of us,” he recalled. Indeed, when doing due diligence on candidates, Google searches would turn up records from TipRanks on various candidates. Gruenbaum is unapologetic about that kind of transparency. “Look, if you’re a research company, if a candidate is good, or average or has underperformed, if that’s going to stop you from finding a job, that is good. That’s how it should be. You’re not supposed to give advice if you don’t know what you’re saying,” he said.

He says that now that TipRanks has grown in size and reach, it’s less likely to get those calls. Now, he said, most of the time when they get contacted by analysts, it’s to update their profile pictures.

The company has built the mainstay of its business around the U.S. stock market and English-language chatter and content, but in more recent years it’s also expanded into Canada and Europe. In addition to making some acquisitions, part of its future plans will be to create more material in localized languages. While the institutional and enterprise opportunity is an immense one, Gruenbaum said the main focus will remain on more tools and access for individual users — something Prytek is also keen to develop.

“We spotted TipRanks’ potential to democratize investment information nearly a decade ago and knew we wanted to be part of their journey,” Andrey Yashunsky, founder of Prytek, said in a statement. “With our strong performing financial services division, having a resource which has revolutionised access to investment insights, data and news will shape the future of our ever-expanding value chain.”

Updated to clarify the ownership stake in this deal.

Read More

Meta axed CrowdTangle, a tool for tracking disinformation. Critics claim its replacement has just ‘1% of the features’

Journalists, researchers and politicians are mourning Meta’s shutdown of CrowdTangle, which they used to track the spread of disinformation on Facebook and Instagram.

In CrowdTangle’s place, Meta is offering its Content Library — but is limiting usage to people from “qualified academic or nonprofit institutions who are pursuing scientific or public interest research.” Many researchers and academics, and most journalists, are barred from accessing the tool. 

Those who have been using the Meta Content Library say it is less transparent and accessible, has fewer features and has a worse user experience design. 

Many people in the community have written open letters to Meta in protest. They question why the company axed a useful tool for combating misinformation three months ahead of the most contentious U.S. election in history — an election that is already threatened by the proliferation of AI deepfakes and chatbot misinformation, some of which has come from Meta’s own chatbot — and replaced it with a tool that academics say is simply not as effective.

In short, if it ain’t broke, why fix it?

Meta hasn’t provided many answers. At an MIT Technology Review conference in May, Meta’s president of global affairs Nick Clegg was asked why the company wouldn’t wait to shut down CrowdTangle until after the election. He called CrowdTangle a “degrading tool” that doesn’t provide complete and accurate insights into what’s happening on Facebook.

“It only measures a narrow cake slice of a cake slice, which is particular forms of engagement,” said Clegg at the time. “It literally doesn’t tell you what people are seeing online.”

His rhetoric paints CrowdTangle as an almost recklessly bad tool for Meta to allow to exist. That’s in stark contrast to Meta’s promotion of the platform in 2020 as a source provided to Secretaries of State and election boards across the country to help them “quickly identify misinformation, voter interference and suppression” and create custom “public Live Displays for each state.”

Today, Meta’s hard line is that the Content Library provides more detailed insights about what people actually see and experience on Facebook and Instagram. A spokesperson from Meta told TechCrunch the new tools offer a more comprehensive data gathering experience. 

Some researchers who were accustomed to the old tool disagree.

“It’s only 10% of the usability of CrowdTangle,” Cameron Hickey, CEO of the National Conference on Citizenship, told TechCrunch. He pointed out that CrowdTangle was “a sophisticated quasi-commercial product” with its own business before Facebook acquired it in 2016. Under the Facebook umbrella, the tool only improved as the team onboarded feature recommendations from a large pool of users. Hickey helped author a report that compares the features on the two platforms, co-published by Proof News and the Tow Center for Digital Journalism at Columbia’s Journalism School.

Hickey said Meta’s content library offers some of the same data from CrowdTangle, but ultimately only “1% of the features.”

“If you wanted to look at the number of followers that CNN’s Facebook page has had over time, that’s something you can’t do in the Meta Content Library, but you can do in CrowdTangle,” said Hickey. “And indicators like that are often very useful for understanding how the prevalence or prominence of an actor on social media changes over time, and connecting those to other things, like, did they make a viral post and then suddenly their total number of followers doubled?”

Research from Proof News, the Tow Center for Digital Journalism and Algorithmic Transparency Institute detailing how Meta Content Library’s features stack up to CrowdTangle, which Meta shut down Wednesday.Image Credits: TechCrunch | Proof News, Tow Center for Journalism, Algorithmic Transparency Institute

Some of the features that exist across both platforms — like tracking how often political parties post about certain topics and seeing the relative engagement — are simply more tedious to do on MCL, says Hickey, which points to poor user experience design. 

Crucially, even though people might be able to access data — say, about posts that mentioned immigration — what they can do with that data is considerably more limited. 

“You can’t build out the kinds of interactive charts that were available with CrowdTangle,” said Hickey. “You can’t build out public dashboards. And most importantly…you can’t download all of the posts.”

Users can only download posts for accounts that have greater than 25,000 followers, but many politicians fall well short of that count. 

“This leaves a lot of researchers with very few options, and one of the only remaining ones is one that has complications, which is scraping the data directly,” said Hickey. 

Another main problem with MCL is that Meta is not granting access to watchdogs that previously used CrowdTangle to track misinformation’s spread. 

Media Matters, a nonprofit watchdog journalism organization, told TechCrunch it doesn’t have access to MCL today. In the past, the organization used CrowdTangle to show that contrary to right-wing media and Republican talking points, Facebook was not actually censoring conservative information. 

In fact, right-leaning pages got considerably more engagement on their content compared to non-aligned or left-leaning pages, research director Kayla Gogarty told TechCrunch.

“CrowdTangle has given us the ability to see the sorts of content that is widely engaged with on the platform,” Gogarty said. “Algorithms are usually a black box, but at least having some of that engagement data could help us learn a little more about the algorithms.”

Gogarty pointed out that ahead of the January 6 attack on Capitol Hill, researchers and reporters used the tool to sound the alarm about online organizing and the potential for violence to delegitimize the election. 

“What this ultimately is going to mean is just that fewer civil society groups are able to monitor and track what’s happening on Facebook and Instagram during this election year,” Brandi Geurkink, executive director of the Coalition for Independent Technology Research, told TechCrunch.

Hickey contrasted Meta, which did spend time and probably millions of dollars to create the Content Library, with Elon Musk’s actions at Twitter (now X). When Musk bought Twitter, he immediately limited access to the Twitter API, which allows developers, journalists and researchers to access and analyze data from the platform in a similar fashion to CrowdTangle. Now, the price tag on the cheapest enterprise X API package is $42,000 a month, and it provides access to only 50 million posts.

Read More

Cockroach Labs shakes up its licensing to force bigger companies to pay

Cockroach Labs, the business and core developer behind the eponymous distributed SQL database known as CockroachDB, is changing its licensing once again — five years after it moved on from an open source model.

The company revealed today that it’s consolidating its self-hosted product under a single enterprise license, a move designed to encourage larger businesses to step up and pay for the features they really need. All customers with more than $10 million in annual revenue will now have to pay a fee based on the number of CPUs or CPU cores within the server system where the database is deployed — essentially, the bigger the database deployment, the bigger the cost.

At the same time, startups below this revenue threshold will be able to use the exact same enterprise version at no cost, in the hope that they may reach a size that will eventually require them to pay for these premium features.

Cockroach Labs co-founder and CEO Spencer Kimball says the threshold will be self-attesting, meaning nobody will be asked to prove revenues.

“It’s just an honor system — most businesses that ought to be paying us aren’t going to lie about something like that,” Kimball said in an interview with TechCrunch. “We’ve provided a very good core product that has now crossed a threshold in terms of reliability and capabilities, and in order to build our business we need companies to pay us rather than being free riders. And you can’t blame them — we’re giving these big companies our software for free. But that’s what we’re changing here.”

The announcement comes amid a swathe of licensing changes in the enterprise software space, underscoring the perennial struggle between open source and proprietary. In the past 12 months, HashiCorp switched its “infrastructure as code” software Terraform to a source-available license, while Element transitioned key elements of Matrix, the decentralized communication protocol, to a less-permissive open source license — similar to Grafana before it. App performance management platform Sentry, meanwhile, created an entirely new license called the Functional Source License (FSL) designed to “grant freedom without harmful free-riding.”

Cockroach Labs is no stranger to shaking things up around licensing. But by moving all self-host deployments under a single license — ignoring the specific features a developer or company might need — it’s further blurring the many lines that exist across the “software freedoms” spectrum.

“We’re trying to ensure that we’re giving a better product to our smaller customers as an investment, and on the higher end trying to find that right balance where there is a fair exchange of value,” Kimball said.

How Cockroach Labs started

Cockroach Labs is the handiwork of Kimball, Peter Mattis (CTO) and Ben Darnell (chief architect). But before all that, way back in the nineties, Kimball and Mattis created the GNU Image Manipulation Program (GIMP), which is like a pared-down, open source version of Photoshop. After a decade-long stint at Google, they founded a photo-sharing app called Viewfinder in 2011, with their former Google colleague Darnell joining them the following year.

Viewfinder shuttered in 2013 after Square acquired the startup’s founding team. The seed of CockroachDB was sown during their time at Square, with the first commit to the open source project made in February, 2014.

Kimball, Mattis and Darnell left Square to form Cockroach Labs in early 2015, quickly raised a seed round of funding from backers including Google Ventures and Sequoia, and launched the public beta of CockroachDB the following year. In the intervening years, Cockroach Labs has raised north of $600 million at a valuation of $5 billion with CockroachDB gaining traction among developers for its promise as a resilient, scalable database capable of handling all manner of outages, with data distributed and balanced across multiple nodes.

However, as with just about every major business built on an open source foundation, Cockroach Labs transitioned away from an open source Apache 2.0 license in 2019 to protect its own efforts to sell services off the back of CockroachDB.

Cockroach Labs CEO Spencer Kimball.Image Credits: Cockroach Labs

Why vendors are going ‘source available’

It’s a familiar story: A major cloud provider starts selling its own managed version of an open source project, bypassing the company and core developers who contribute most of the code. Amazon is often at the center of these spats, with notable examples including Elasticsearch’s license switch to prevent AWS from monetizing Elastic’s hard work.

While the hyperscalers are perfectly within their rights to do this under the terms of the open source license, companies such as Elastic and Cockroach Labs have fought this trend by switching to a “source available” license. This offers many of the freedoms of a traditional open source license, but with one key difference: Developers aren’t allowed to sell a commercial version of the product “as-a-service,” without paying for a license.

Within this licensing model, Cockroach Labs’ customers have always been able to self-host CockroachDB. This includes a free version aimed at smaller companies, freelance developers or students, and an enterprise incarnation with sugar on top, including disaster recovery tooling, enhanced security, cluster optimization and support.

However, Kimball says they identified two issues with this setup: startups wanted some of the enterprise features, but were unable or unwilling to pay for them all; and larger businesses were compromising their own use of CockroachDB just to save money, sticking with the free version even when the enterprise version made the most sense.

“Our ‘core’ [free] offering has become one of our savviest competitors,” Kimball said. “The reason that’s true today, but wasn’t necessarily true two years ago, is that the product quality has gotten to the point where you can go a long time without having any kind of support needs. That’s amazing, and we’re happy to deliver that level of quality to our customers. But on the other hand, particularly when macroeconomic times are tighter, we’ve seen that some companies will forgo the enterprise contract — which comes with a better level of support — because they ask themselves how many times they’ve had a support ticket in the past year.”

The licensing change will start November 18, when Cockroach Labs will launch CockroachDB version 24.3. While the current self-hosted product has a bunch of different licenses attached to it covering different parts of the codebase, the new Enterprise tier will have a single license which the company is calling the CockroachDB Software License (none of these changes impact Cockroach Labs’ existing cloud product).

“By making all of the enterprise features free to these earlier-stage companies, we’re investing in them, we’re giving them an enterprise-grade product,” Kimball added. “In return, we hope that this helps them succeed, and they cross that $10 million annual revenue threshold. It’s a quid pro quo that makes a lot of sense.”

The future of open source

As all these various licensing transitions pile up, it may be tempting to believe that open source is dead. But the matter isn’t quite so simple. Open source components permeate most of the software world, including CockroachDB itself, which relies on many third-party libraries, languages and toolkits. The company also continues to open source some of its own internal technologies, such as its Pebble key-value store, which it created to replace an open source alternative developed by Meta called RocksDB.

The same is true across the technological landscape, evidenced by the likes of Spotify, which is morphing into a developer tooling company by monetizing its own open source efforts.

So open source is far from dead, but it is on shaky footing — particularly around fully fledged commercial, vendor-driven projects, judging by the events over the past five years and more.

“I believe that the software component side of open source is going to continue to thrive — it’s super valuable, and I don’t see that going away,” Kimball said. “But with finished products, the reality is that the best way to really monetize them in 2024 is to build a service around it. And once you build a service, almost everything starts to trend towards closed-source. Because if you simply build everything in open source for your service, someone else can come along and just build a service on it too.”

Read More